
What troubles me about much of contemporary Anglicanism, including parts of ACNA and GAFCON, is the apparent drift toward consumerism: the constant emphasis on growth, accessibility, relevance, and attracting people, sometimes at the expense of truth, reverence, holiness, and the fullness of the Christian faith. Of course, numbers are not inherently wrong—the Church is called to evangelize and make disciples—but numerical growth cannot become the measure of faithfulness.
Christ Himself did not dilute difficult truths when people turned away; He allowed them to leave rather than reshape His message to retain them. The Church is not a religious marketplace in which we give people whatever they find attractive. It is the Body of Christ, entrusted with the apostolic faith and called to worship God, proclaim the whole counsel of Scripture, administer the sacraments, form people in holiness, and make disciples. Anglicanism at its best understood this: the Church forms the Christian; the consumer does not design the Church.
So the real question should not simply be, “How many people are we attracting?” but, “Are we faithfully proclaiming Christ, preserving the truth, and actually forming people into His likeness?” If truth becomes negotiable whenever it threatens growth, then we have ceased to treat truth as truth and have begun treating Christianity as a product.
