
Father Flourish Klink, a nonbinary and transgender Episcopal priest at Christ & St. Stephen’s Church on Manhattan’s Upper West Side, recently sparked controversy during a sermon by claiming that God is nonbinary and that Jesus Christ was transgender. Klink, who uses the pronouns they, elle, and hen, argued that much like transgender individuals whose assigned gender at birth does not align with their true selves, Jesus experienced a similar dynamic. Referencing the Nativity, Klink suggested that Mary mistakenly identified Jesus as a boy based on physical observation, asserting that because God transcends traditional gender categories, Jesus ultimately lived and was resurrected beyond male and female norms.
Klink further supported this theological interpretation by pointing to biblical accounts of the resurrection. Noting that Jesus’s closest disciples initially failed to recognize him after he rose from the dead, Klink theorized that this transformation represented Jesus transitioning into his true, gender-transcendent self. Additional arguments included Jesus’s non-traditional life choices, such as remaining unmarried and engaging extensively with women, which Klink contrasted with first-century masculine standards.

The sermon quickly drew sharp criticism online, with many commentators labeling the remarks blasphemous and questioning the theological validity of the claims. Critics and social media users pushed back by citing specific biblical passages, such as the Gospel of Luke where the angel Gabriel explicitly tells Mary she will bear a son, and various New Testament verses that consistently refer to Jesus using male pronouns. A community note was subsequently added to the viral social media post to highlight these scriptural contradictions.
The controversy also drew comparisons to similar remarks made by Texas Democratic Senate candidate James Talarico. While serving as a state representative in 2021, Talarico similarly stated that God is nonbinary and encompasses both masculine and feminine traits. Talarico later acknowledged that his previous comments were deliberately provocative, clarifying that his intent was simply to emphasize that God transcends human categorization rather than to advance a literal gender identity.

