Tornatore’s, the popular College Park restaurant and pizzeria, has been voted first place in our 2022 Best Pizza Foodster Award for Independent Restaurants.

Bella Roma of Saint Cloud was second and Stone Fired Pizza, Edgewood, came in third.

“Tornatore’s reminds me of New York,” wrote Ross Recchion after placing his vote. Wendy N. Lowe said: “The product is always very fresh and delicious. The staff is amazing. Best around.”

Rosa Jimenez called Bella Pizza “awesome” and mentioned the “great service.” “We enjoy it there every time,” she wrote in her comment. Kaitlyn Gardner said, “Stone Fired is fairly priced and delicious.”

Tornatore’s Cafe & Pizzeria – College Park
Tartini’s Pizza & Spagetteria – Pine Castle
Francesco’s – Maitland (Orlando Ave & Horatio)
Two Guys Pizzeria – East Colonial / SR 408
Bella Roma – Saint Cloud
Goodfellas Pizza – East Colonial / Alafaya
Stone Fired Pizza – Pine Castle
LeMay’s Pizza – Poinciana
Don Giovanni Contemporary Italian and Pizzeria – Port Orange
Buttercrust – South Orange Ave (Gatlin Plaza)
Touch of Basil – St Cloud